About

Home of the Finest Prime Rib and Steaks in the McFarland Area. Visit Maple Tree Supper Club, one of the best restaurants in the Madison, WI, metropolitan area for exceptional dining in a comfortable friendly atmosphere.

Available Deals

Hours

Tuesday 4:00 PM - 8:30 PM
Wednesday 4:00 PM - 8:30 PM
Thursday 4:00 PM - 8:30 PM
Friday 4:00 PM - 9:30 PM
Saturday 4:00 PM - 9:30 PM

Amenities & Services

Dine-in Takeout Dinner
Lynn P. Verified visit ★★★★★


Sarah E. Verified visit ★★★★★


Charles K. Verified visit ★★★★★

We love their salad bar. We were there on Tuesday and I always get the meatloaf special which is huge. I take at least... We love their salad bar. We were there on Tuesday and I always get the meatloaf special which is huge. I take at least half home and also the baked potato. My husband gets ribs & chicken and he takes his chicken & baked potato home. So we each get 2 meals for the price of one which is very reasonable to start with. Several people we have talked with also rave about the salad bar. We go there at least once a month. Read more Read less


Jeff W. Verified visit ★★★★★

We had a great visit. We had the Thursday night special, swiss steak and it was excellent. Large portions and a very goo... We had a great visit. We had the Thursday night special, swiss steak and it was excellent. Large portions and a very good variety at the salad and soup bar. Delicious soup. We go early and that insures immediate seating. Will definitely go there again. Read more Read less


Brian M. Verified visit ★★★★★

Great prime rib. Decent salad bar. Good service. We will go back.


Lawrence W. Verified visit ★☆☆☆☆

Mediocre place Poor food. Salad bar was terrible. Ribs were awful. Water dripped on my wife's head from a/c vent. Even... Mediocre place Poor food. Salad bar was terrible. Ribs were awful. Water dripped on my wife's head from a/c vent. Even the tables and chairs looked lreally cheap.. Read more Read less


Terri L. Verified visit ★☆☆☆☆

Had to wait an hour and a half for our food. Kept telling it was because we ordered lobster, although some of the other... Had to wait an hour and a half for our food. Kept telling it was because we ordered lobster, although some of the other tables had lobster around us and they got theres. I ordered my steak med well and it came back rare. The waitress was so busy that she never checked back with us so I could let her know. Didnt see her again until we were waiting for our bill. I still had my steak on my plate uneaten. She did offer to take back and cook longer but after taking an hour and a half already, and my husband was done eating, I just declined. She offered to take my meal off, but was still charged 12.00 for the salad bar! I would have thought they would have just taken my whole meal off. The waitress was very nice, i just think she was overwhelmed with having to serve the whole waiting room. I blame this on the restaurant....they should have more help. Thought we would try it..... we did and will not be back. Read more Read less


Jennifer H. Verified visit ★★★★★


Sharon V. Verified visit ★★★★★


Terrie S. Verified visit ★★★★★

Great food and service with a smile. TS


Anonymous Verified visit ★★☆☆☆

We got their on a Saturday night around 4:30pm. Got seated right away. Salad bar was fair, lettuce looked liked it was... We got their on a Saturday night around 4:30pm. Got seated right away. Salad bar was fair, lettuce looked liked it was from the night before. I had the ribs which were not good. No meat what-so-ever. Husband had the prime rib which was just warm and a little tough. We would try the fish or chicken if we go back again. Alot of chicken was being served that night. Read more Read less


Joan H. Verified visit ★★★☆☆

We were lucky to get seated right as we got there, as not too much after that, it got very crowded. Salad bar was superb... We were lucky to get seated right as we got there, as not too much after that, it got very crowded. Salad bar was superb with wonderful beef barley soup and fresh offerings. Our party of four all ordered the prime rib. We all agreed it was good but not great. Mine had a crazy large amount of fat right in the center, which I've never experienced before. I still had plenty to eat, but the edible part was much smaller than my dinner mates'. Hashbrowns were dry and barely warm, but since it was so busy, we let it go. Our waitress was stellar as she was serving a large amount of tables and did it well with a pleasant demeaner. For the price, I'd say it was a good deal, but it could be better with a nicer cut of meat and a closer eye on the sides. Read more Read less


Christina K. Verified visit ★★★☆☆

Went here for the Wednesday buffet. Soup and salad bar were good. Food not so great. No beef option. A meatloaf would ha... Went here for the Wednesday buffet. Soup and salad bar were good. Food not so great. No beef option. A meatloaf would have been nice. The ravioli and Mac and cheese were not very good. Mashed potatoes were good. I’m told they have an excellent fish fry so I guess Friday is the night to go Read more Read less


Angela H. Verified visit ★★★★★

Great food. Great service. Huge portions and delicious salad bar and soup. Fresh out or the oven bread. Always a great p... Great food. Great service. Huge portions and delicious salad bar and soup. Fresh out or the oven bread. Always a great place to go. Read more Read less


Sherri H. Verified visit ★★★★★

We LOVE Maple Tree. We eat here at least twice a month. The food, the price and the service is top notch.


Charles K. Verified visit ★★★★★

Our favorite restaurant for the delicious soup & salad bar, prime rib, broasted chicken & ribs. For special occasions w... Our favorite restaurant for the delicious soup & salad bar, prime rib, broasted chicken & ribs. For special occasions we start with a screw driver and end with a (half) grasshopper, which comes in a high ball glass. We try to treat ourselves about once a month. Read more Read less


Linda P. Verified visit ★★★★★

We had a couple drinks at the bar before dinner and they were very enjoyable, as always. Salad bar was well stocked, th... We had a couple drinks at the bar before dinner and they were very enjoyable, as always. Salad bar was well stocked, there was chili (excellent) and a chicken soup with lots of vegetables as well. The chili was so good I'm afraid neither of us were very hungry for supper when it arrived. Excellent prime rib, I got fried shrimp with mine and they too were excellent. Good thing the prime rib reheats well. Thank you for a lovely evening! Read more Read less


Agnes A. ★☆☆☆☆

We were seated immediately after arriving. The waitress was efficient and helpful. However, we both had major gastric... We were seated immediately after arriving. The waitress was efficient and helpful. However, we both had major gastric issues after eating at this restaurant. This was more than just gas or a little upset. Within an hour, it was awful. We had different dishes, so I'm guessing it was the salad bar that caused it. Read more Read less


Michele D. Verified visit ★★★★★

Great food and service.

Show more reviews Show less